Florian Lohoff
RouteQA2: How to use - Part 1
So now that RouteQA2 is running for
Germany for a week i share some ways of how i use it to
debug routing in Openstreetmap. I am doing that since 2013 so
one gets a trained eye for things which are not obvious.
First lets have a look at the Grid. Its basically the sum of all routes,
unified by their segments. Each segment gets counts on how many routes
it is used by, which clusters these
So now that RouteQA2 is running for
Germany for a week i share some ways of how i use it to
debug routing in Openstreetmap. I am doing that since 2013 so
one gets a trained eye for things which are not obvious.
First lets have a look at the Grid. Its basically the sum of all routes,
unified by their segments. Each segment gets counts on how many routes
it is used by, which clusters these routes belong too and links to some
of the routes.
As all nodes we calculate routes between are on the higher class network,
e.g. tertiary or better, the assumption is that all routes are basically
"through traffic" and should not leave the higher class road network.
So when looking at the grid a lot of violations of this assumption can be
seen, and sometimes even be fixed.
For example see this screenshot. You can see a thin blue line passing through
a farmyard. Its thin because its only a few routes, possibly only a single one.
Looking at the data it shows all the road segments are only tagged
highway=service not a driveway. So routing assumes it okay to use it. So -
retag it as service=driveway and the issue should be gone.
But even further. By inspecting the aerial imagery one can see gates or
lift gates in all directions. Adding the gates, and the inner road segments
with access=private.
After 30 minutes you can see routing has changed. The road segments on
the farmyard have vanished from the grid. They will be shown for the
next 24h as red dotted lines fading lighter over time.
And this is how it looks for a single route in the notification when
the check came back. You see the old and the new route. And the changeset
bounding boxes.
So now that RouteQA2 is running for Germany for a week i share some ways of how i use it to debug routing in Openstreetmap. I am doing that since 2013 so one gets a trained eye for things which are not obvious.
First lets have a look at the Grid. Its basically the sum of all routes, unified by their segments. Each segment gets counts on how many routes it is used by, which clusters these
So now that RouteQA2 is running for Germany for a week i share some ways of how i use it to debug routing in Openstreetmap. I am doing that since 2013 so one gets a trained eye for things which are not obvious.
First lets have a look at the Grid. Its basically the sum of all routes, unified by their segments. Each segment gets counts on how many routes it is used by, which clusters these routes belong too and links to some of the routes.
As all nodes we calculate routes between are on the higher class network, e.g. tertiary or better, the assumption is that all routes are basically "through traffic" and should not leave the higher class road network.
So when looking at the grid a lot of violations of this assumption can be seen, and sometimes even be fixed.
For example see this screenshot. You can see a thin blue line passing through a farmyard. Its thin because its only a few routes, possibly only a single one.
Looking at the data it shows all the road segments are only tagged
highway=service not a driveway. So routing assumes it okay to use it. So -
retag it as service=driveway and the issue should be gone.
But even further. By inspecting the aerial imagery one can see gates or
lift gates in all directions. Adding the gates, and the inner road segments
with access=private.
After 30 minutes you can see routing has changed. The road segments on the farmyard have vanished from the grid. They will be shown for the next 24h as red dotted lines fading lighter over time.
And this is how it looks for a single route in the notification when the check came back. You see the old and the new route. And the changeset bounding boxes.
OpenStreetMap Blogs














