OpenStreetMap User's Diaries
OSMLondon at The Volunteer pub!
The next London OSM meet-up will be December 9th at the Monkey Puzzle.
Last time we were at “The Volunteer” pub! Obviously with a name like that, I hoped this would be a good pub for us to have our gathering of volunteer mappers, and to show solidarity with the unpaid bar staff. But it turns out this pub was pretty noisy and busy, and what’s more, I suspect the staff were actually being
The next London OSM meet-up will be December 9th at the Monkey Puzzle.
Last time we were at “The Volunteer” pub! Obviously with a name like that, I hoped this would be a good pub for us to have our gathering of volunteer mappers, and to show solidarity with the unpaid bar staff. But it turns out this pub was pretty noisy and busy, and what’s more, I suspect the staff were actually being paid :-) I booked a table for 8 but got a table with four places. I suppose the idea was that it’s big enough for 8 people to drink around, which we put to the test, and then about 12 people arrived, and then we ordered food. So it was a bit of squeeze, but fun!

User spiregrain was there (impressive editing run!). He’s from Statford, so we talked about mapping there, and we were remembering having a massive Westfield shopping mall mapping party there. Looking back at the old diary entry now, I see this was 2011. I’d forgotten we organised to go there shortly after the mall opened.
Terrence Eden was at the pub! I feel like I could’ve chatted to him all evening about the fascinating tech topics (and indeed other topics) I’ve read about on his blog, but keeping it OSM-adjacent, I asked him about OpenBenches.org, the bench-themed crowd-sourced open geodata project! I did some bench mapping recently during the 31 Day OSM Challenge. I only mapped boring benches in OSM for that, but I have added benches (including photos of benches) into OpenBenches in the past, generally when I find a really good juicey bench.
OpenBenches has operated and inter-operated with OpenStreetMap for many years now. It is a separate database, so not like things like wheelmap.org where OSM is the database, and it’s not synced in any automated way, but we do tag OpenBenches ids in OSM, and there are some mechanisms for user-driven syncing, the main one being mapcomplete.org/benches. I was saying I found myself wanting a tool to look through all the benches I have added to OpenStreetMap, to sync & conflate that data into OpenBenches and vice versa. Thinking more widely I don’t know if we’ve found the best way to organise these kinds of parallel geodatabases (and there are many other examples). We don’t particularly want OpenStreetMap to be the one and only centralised source for such things (although the wheelmap.org approach does work well). Automated syncing is possible but fraught with problems, and so we drift into this kind of loosely-coupled community-driven ad-hoc syncing situation.
And then Michiel Riechart User:Nakaner walked into the pub! He’s very busy in all things OSM, working at geofabrik in Karlsruhe, and apparently he decided to pop over to London because he was making the most out of an interrail ticket. True to form as a railway obsessive! (He operates openrailwaymap.org and has given some SOTM talks on how to do ludicrously detailed railway signal mapping). Being such a noisy pub I don’t know if he himself had railway mapping conversations, but on my side of the table he was inspiring others to talk about railway mapping by his mere presence!
We talked about sysadmin challenges dealing with overzealous scraping by/for AIs. Firefishy and TomH have been working hard to keep a lid on it with OpenStreetMap sites. Maybe the topic also came up because Terrence has had his own battles with the bots lately. I heard wikimedia have been trying to contact scraper organisations and ask them nicely. I see isolated success stories but presumably that isn’t a full solution. No doubt they’re still spending a lot of resources on fending off abusive traffic hitting the wikipedia website.
We also chatted about good old spam, which feels quaint by comparison. Firefishy told us how OSM accounts can be erroneously closed as spammer accounts sometimes. One particular source of mistakes has been u-map. That system allows users to register by authorizing with an OpenStreetMap account. That in turn means that some folks end up creating an OSM account purely for their interactions over on one particular umap. These might be people who know very little about OpenStreetMap, but they might well create a profile description including links which they’ll write in relation to whatever the particular umap is about, and the OSM account shows no editing activity within OSM. That can all easily look like spam, and gets wiped. Not sure whether this is considered a big problem for OSM/u-map, or what solutions have been discussed, but it seems to me u-map should probably support more login providers, and get these rolled out on more instances. For example I see umap.openstreetmap.de only supports login with an OSM account.
User profile description spam in general is much more common than people trying to spam the map data or anything more sophisticated like that. Just automated web bots registering and putting spammy links on their profile description. Mostly zapped in an automated way too, but some profile spam can look vaguely map-adjacent. Me and Matt were laughing about spam claiming to offer “Best plumber in London”. As London home-owners, the phone number of a genuinely good plumber is like gold dust! So we decided we need a new policy: A user should be allowed to keep their “Best plumber in London” profile, but only if they come round and fix our plumbing problems! :-)
Clearly our solutionizing was getting more silly as the evening progressed. The pub wasn’t getting any quieter either as after-work crowds gave way to crowds of trendy-looking young people. We fitted right in of course. And the staff gave us all a free slab of cheese cake at the end of the night. Maybe the pudding chef is the volunteer!
That was fun. Maybe next time will be even more fun because it’s the Christmas meet-up! Come join us at the good old Monkey Puzzle pub in Paddington on December 9th. More details on the wiki
The next London OSM meet-up will be December 9th at the Monkey Puzzle.
Last time we were at “The Volunteer” pub! Obviously with a name like that, I hoped this would be a good pub for us to have our gathering of volunteer mappers, and to show solidarity with the unpaid bar staff. But it turns out this pub was pretty noisy and busy, and what’s more, I suspect the staff were actually being
The next London OSM meet-up will be December 9th at the Monkey Puzzle.
Last time we were at “The Volunteer” pub! Obviously with a name like that, I hoped this would be a good pub for us to have our gathering of volunteer mappers, and to show solidarity with the unpaid bar staff. But it turns out this pub was pretty noisy and busy, and what’s more, I suspect the staff were actually being paid :-) I booked a table for 8 but got a table with four places. I suppose the idea was that it’s big enough for 8 people to drink around, which we put to the test, and then about 12 people arrived, and then we ordered food. So it was a bit of squeeze, but fun!

User spiregrain was there (impressive editing run!). He’s from Statford, so we talked about mapping there, and we were remembering having a massive Westfield shopping mall mapping party there. Looking back at the old diary entry now, I see this was 2011. I’d forgotten we organised to go there shortly after the mall opened.
Terrence Eden was at the pub! I feel like I could’ve chatted to him all evening about the fascinating tech topics (and indeed other topics) I’ve read about on his blog, but keeping it OSM-adjacent, I asked him about OpenBenches.org, the bench-themed crowd-sourced open geodata project! I did some bench mapping recently during the 31 Day OSM Challenge. I only mapped boring benches in OSM for that, but I have added benches (including photos of benches) into OpenBenches in the past, generally when I find a really good juicey bench.
OpenBenches has operated and inter-operated with OpenStreetMap for many years now. It is a separate database, so not like things like wheelmap.org where OSM is the database, and it’s not synced in any automated way, but we do tag OpenBenches ids in OSM, and there are some mechanisms for user-driven syncing, the main one being mapcomplete.org/benches. I was saying I found myself wanting a tool to look through all the benches I have added to OpenStreetMap, to sync & conflate that data into OpenBenches and vice versa. Thinking more widely I don’t know if we’ve found the best way to organise these kinds of parallel geodatabases (and there are many other examples). We don’t particularly want OpenStreetMap to be the one and only centralised source for such things (although the wheelmap.org approach does work well). Automated syncing is possible but fraught with problems, and so we drift into this kind of loosely-coupled community-driven ad-hoc syncing situation.
And then Michiel Riechart User:Nakaner walked into the pub! He’s very busy in all things OSM, working at geofabrik in Karlsruhe, and apparently he decided to pop over to London because he was making the most out of an interrail ticket. True to form as a railway obsessive! (He operates openrailwaymap.org and has given some SOTM talks on how to do ludicrously detailed railway signal mapping). Being such a noisy pub I don’t know if he himself had railway mapping conversations, but on my side of the table he was inspiring others to talk about railway mapping by his mere presence!
We talked about sysadmin challenges dealing with overzealous scraping by/for AIs. Firefishy and TomH have been working hard to keep a lid on it with OpenStreetMap sites. Maybe the topic also came up because Terrence has had his own battles with the bots lately. I heard wikimedia have been trying to contact scraper organisations and ask them nicely. I see isolated success stories but presumably that isn’t a full solution. No doubt they’re still spending a lot of resources on fending off abusive traffic hitting the wikipedia website.
We also chatted about good old spam, which feels quaint by comparison. Firefishy told us how OSM accounts can be erroneously closed as spammer accounts sometimes. One particular source of mistakes has been u-map. That system allows users to register by authorizing with an OpenStreetMap account. That in turn means that some folks end up creating an OSM account purely for their interactions over on one particular umap. These might be people who know very little about OpenStreetMap, but they might well create a profile description including links which they’ll write in relation to whatever the particular umap is about, and the OSM account shows no editing activity within OSM. That can all easily look like spam, and gets wiped. Not sure whether this is considered a big problem for OSM/u-map, or what solutions have been discussed, but it seems to me u-map should probably support more login providers, and get these rolled out on more instances. For example I see umap.openstreetmap.de only supports login with an OSM account.
User profile description spam in general is much more common than people trying to spam the map data or anything more sophisticated like that. Just automated web bots registering and putting spammy links on their profile description. Mostly zapped in an automated way too, but some profile spam can look vaguely map-adjacent. Me and Matt were laughing about spam claiming to offer “Best plumber in London”. As London home-owners, the phone number of a genuinely good plumber is like gold dust! So we decided we need a new policy: A user should be allowed to keep their “Best plumber in London” profile, but only if they come round and fix our plumbing problems! :-)
Clearly our solutionizing was getting more silly as the evening progressed. The pub wasn’t getting any quieter either as after-work crowds gave way to crowds of trendy-looking young people. We fitted right in of course. And the staff gave us all a free slab of cheese cake at the end of the night. Maybe the pudding chef is the volunteer!
That was fun. Maybe next time will be even more fun because it’s the Christmas meet-up! Come join us at the good old Monkey Puzzle pub in Paddington on December 9th. More details on the wiki
OpenStreetMap Blogs

















